Year: 1990, Director: Roland Emmerich
Year: 2008, Director: Roland Emmerich
i mentioned it briefly on an episode of the podcast a while back, that i actually enjoyed the film 2012. i thought it was a good big summer disaster film with crazy special effects and a story that took a somewhat interesting look at the decisions that mankind would have to make if such an event were to occur. unlike the last disaster film from director roland emmerich, The Day After Tomorrow which is didn't like at all.
anyway, i bring that up, because as i walked out of the film i started to think about mister emmerich and taking a look at some of his lesser known films and if this hit and miss film maker (mostly miss) had some hidden gems out there. and, given that i am writing about these two films on Not Good Movies rather than on Filmed But Not Forgotten, i assume you figured out whether they are hits or misses.
in picking the two films to watch i first went back and found one of his earliest films that i could get my hands on. that was Moon 44. then i checked out his films since the huge success of Independence Day and noticed that 10,000 BC was the only film of his last five that didn't make a profit at the box office and made less than $100 million. so, those seemed like to good ones to check out. or at least they did till i had to sit down and watch them... especially Moon 44.
wow, this is a bad movie. the story takes place in the year 2038 when all resources have been depleted on earth and humans must rely on the mining of other satellites and planets. but when the mining vessels start to disappear an undercover agent is sent to one of the last controlled satellite, Moon 44, to see what is going on.
where to begin with this one? the special effects are passable, the acting is bad (except for the great malcolm mcdowell), the dialogue is forced and so very corny and the characters are caricatures: you have the cool undercover guy, the bad guy prisoners (oh ya, did i mention they are getting prisoners to fly the dangerous helicopter missions on Moon 44 in order to get out of their prison sentences) who are pretty much always angry and bullying the computer nerds (these young guys are the ones that control the helicopters from the main ship).
the movie is boring, corny, predictable and laughable. i think if Mystery Science Theatre 3000 were still on the air they could have a great time with this one. but, otherwise there is no reason for anyone to spend an hour and half of their lives watching this thing. Now as for 10,000 BC my feelings aren't as harsh...
my initial reaction was to jump all over the movie for its complete lack of historical accuracy. i mean, the film is called 10,000 BC, yet the final third of the film takes place during the building of the great pyramids (which weren't built til around 2500 BC from what I read). also, there is a whole melange of american and european accents, horses are domesticated (which i read somewhere wasn't true for the time) and much, much more... but, then i decided to let that go.
first off, maybe my facts are wrong. and second, i assume that the film makers knew that they didn't have their facts straight, which would mean that was the whole point. so, if that was done intentionally, then how is the film beyond those things? well, its still not good.
and you know what. thinking about it - and this also kind of hit me as i watched it - while the film is grand in its idea. and if you were to tell someone the story it would seem pretty vast. watching the movie it didn't have that epicness that it should have.
the heart of the film is one mammoth hunters quest to save the women he loves from the hands of a tribe of horsemen who attacked their clan and kidnapped her and some other tribe members. he chases them through forests, mountains and deserts. fights off large wild animals, befriends other tribes and organizes a slave rebellion against the pharaoh during the building of the pyramids. that all sounds like the makings of a fun blockbuster to me (i actually did want to see this in the theatres when it was released).
but, in the end it is kind of plain and seems unsure of itself - is it a somewhat thoughtful grand action drama or is a big, dont-think-about-it-too-much-and-just-have-fun blockbuster. it looks to try and be both. but, unlike 2012, which did it successfully, 10,000 BC doesn't end up working as either one.